Boar WarsPigs, Property & the DNR

Court Cases

Farmers took the State to court.

The legal fight over vagueness, due process and the right to be compensated when the government takes your property.

Private property. Due process. Proof.

2016 Ruling: The DNR Couldn’t Prove Its Case.

“The utilization of phenotypes to identify Russian boar and hybrids is problematic and can be difficult.”
Judge Charles Goodman · Baraga County Circuit Court · Turunen’s eight pigs · LC No. 2012-006259-CZ

No explicit standard

No clear, explicit standard existed for when a pig with some traits becomes prohibited.

Eight pigs. No complete match.

None of the eight pigs showed all the traits the DNR associated with the banned animals.

The burden was the DNR’s

The DNR failed to meet its burden of proof that any of the pigs were illegal.

The DNR failed to prove that any of the eight pigs were prohibited under the Invasive Species Order.

DNR claimed

These pigs were prohibited Russian boar or hybrids, based on their appearance.

Court found

No reliable, explicit appearance-based standard existed, and the DNR did not meet its burden of proof.

— Judge Charles Goodman rules for Turunen

What happened next. The Michigan Court of Appeals affirmed the finding that these pigs were not unlawful. This finding concerns the eight pigs in this case—not every animal or every later DNR lawsuit.

Verify it yourself — the court record

Turunen v. Director of the Department of Natural Resources

Roger Turunen, d/b/a Hogan Land Improvement Company v. Director of the DNR and Department of Natural Resources

2016 trial ruling
Baraga County Circuit Court, LC No. 2012-006259-CZ — Judge Charles Goodman, Nov. 22, 2016
2021 Court of Appeals
336 Mich. App. 468; 971 N.W.2d 20 (2021), No. 350913 — published opinion

Trial-court rulings are not published online; the 2018 and 2021 Court of Appeals opinions above review and quote the 2016 decision. Both links are free, full-text copies of the official opinions.

Baker’s Green Acres v. DNR

Missaukee County

Vagueness & due process

A family heritage-hog farm challenged the Order, arguing no reasonable farmer could tell from its list of traits whether his pigs were legal.

Upper Peninsula ranch challenges

Upper Peninsula

Takings & search

Ranch owners targeted after undercover hunts contested the seizures and the methods used to gather evidence on private land.

Ranchers’ association suits

State courts

Agency authority

Game ranch operators argued the DNR exceeded its statutory authority by reclassifying livestock through an administrative order.

Case summaries are for public education and are not legal advice. Consult the court record for official rulings.

“If a law is so vague that a farmer can't read it and know whether he's a felon, it isn't a law — it's a trap.”
— Upper Peninsula state legislator